Why #AdoptDontShop Isn’t the Right Fit for Every Family

Why #AdoptDontShop Isn’t the Right Fit for Every Family

“Adopt, don’t shop” has encouraged countless people to give a shelter dog a home. That’s something worth celebrating. But a hashtag can’t answer the question every family needs to ask before bringing home a dog: Can we give this particular dog what they need for their whole life? Sometimes the answer leads a family to a rescue. Sometimes it leads them to an ethical breeder. So harassing anyone who chooses what is best for their family is outright wrong and ignorant.

Every family brings a different set of needs

Imagine a family that already has a senior dog who enjoys quiet company. An adult rescue dog who has lived peacefully with older dogs in a foster home may be a wonderful match. That foster family can describe what happens when another dog approaches the food bowl, wants to play, or simply needs to rest.

Another family may have the time and desire to raise a puppy from the beginning. They may want to meet the mother, review both parents’ health records, and talk with someone who has watched the litter grow. A family with young children might especially value knowing which puppy recovers comfortably after a sudden noise and which one prefers a quieter room. Those observations give families something more meaningful to consider than which puppy has the cutest markings.

Why ethical breeders matter for healthier puppies

Some of the most important decisions a breeder makes happen before a puppy is conceived. A dog can look healthy, enjoy long walks, and have a beautiful coat while still carrying a genetic variant that could affect its puppies. An ethical breeder considers both parents’ test results together and is willing to change a planned pairing when those results reveal an avoidable risk. The Orthopedic Foundation for Animals recommends screenings based on the conditions relevant to each breed and encourages breeders to make results available to the public.

For families considering an English Goldendoodle or Bernedoodle, one of the best questions to ask is “Can you show me the results for both parents and explain why you chose this pairing?” A puppy’s veterinary exam tells you how that puppy appears to be doing today. The parents’ genetic, orthopedic, eye, and cardiac evaluations answer different questions about inherited risk. Screening can reduce certain risks, although no breeder can promise a lifetime free of illness.

What that looks like at DoodleDee

Here at DoodleDee Goldendoodles & More in Chesterton, Indiana, we’ve been raising dogs since 2000. Health and temperament guide our breeding decisions. Our parent dogs receive complete genetic and orthopedic testing, along with OFA eye and basic cardiac evaluations.

Our English Goldendoodle and Bernedoodle puppies grow up inside our home. They hear the vacuum while we clean, feel a brush move through their coat, and begin stepping outside for potty breaks on turf at around four weeks old. These ordinary moments matter because they’re part of the life our puppies will share with their families. They also give us time to notice the little differences between littermates and share those observations with the people who will love them next.

You can care deeply about shelter dogs and still choose a responsibly bred puppy. If you adopt, ask what the rescue has learned about the dog in its care. If you choose a breeder, ask to see the parents’ health results, learn how the puppies spend their days, and find out who will be there if your circumstances change. Whichever path you take, the goal is a dog whose needs you understand and a home prepared to meet them.

Why Do People Shame Families for Buying From a Breeder?

For some people, it starts with a dog they know. A shelter volunteer may have spent weeks helping a gentle dog find a home. When they hear that someone bought a puppy, they picture that dog still waiting. Others have seen the harm caused by puppy mills and worry that buying a puppy supports those conditions. Those concerns come from a place of compassion. The shaming happens when someone assumes they know how a particular puppy was raised or what another family needs.

There’s also an assumption behind #AdoptDontShop that deserves a closer look. If a family hadn’t bought a puppy, would they have adopted a shelter dog? Some would. Others might have waited years or decided to go without a dog. A family can care deeply about rescue dogs and still value the chance to review both parents’ health records, learn how a puppy has been raised, and build a relationship with the person who bred that litter.

At DoodleDee, we welcome questions about those choices. “Can I see both parents’ health results?” and “What made you choose this pairing?” are fair questions that breeders should be ready to answer. Asking them helps families make informed decisions and holds breeders accountable for the puppies they bring into the world. There’s room to celebrate a rescue dog finding a home and to be happy for a family welcoming a responsibly bred puppy.

Bethany Dills

Ethical Breeder of Fully Health Tested English Teddy Bear Goldendoodles & Bernedoodles.

https://DoodleDeeGoldendoodle.com
Next
Next

Holistic Remedies for Dogs: Gentle Home Care for Itchy Skin, Upset Stomachs, Stiff Joints, and Anxiety